3 Songs, 3 DAW's, Part 1 - Logic Pro 9

I've finally completed the first entry of my "3 Songs, 3 DAW's" experiment. For those who don't care to read my ramblings below and simply want to hear the track, here it is...

Avid's Pro Tools was my introduction to computer-based recording, and has since been my recording platform of choice. It wasn't my introduction to digital recording in general, because I'd been using (and still own) an 8-track digital recorder called the Roland VS-880EX since 1999, then got my first Macintosh G4 in 2003 to run Pro Tools LE. As time went on, I would read about the intriguingly cool features of other DAW's on the market, and figured this project would be a good way to explore what other DAW's have to offer, and satisfy my curiosity.

I recorded and mixed the song above in Apple's Logic Pro. Much like Apple's computer hardware lines, many of their software titles are divided into "professional" and "consumer" categories. In the case of their audio software, Logic Pro is their "professional" DAW, the "consumer" level  program being their also-excellent Garageband, which comes installed with a new Mac computer purchase.

Logic's history actually goes back to the early 90's, originally developed by a company called Emagic, and then was purchased by Apple in 2002. Logic has been a Mac-only program for a while now, but before Apple bought Logic, it was available for both the Mac and Windows. Once Logic became an Apple product, they initially had two versions, Logic Pro and Logic Express, which is my first experience with the software, and I later upgraded to the Pro version. Apple have since discontinued Logic Express, and now carry on with Logic Pro and Garageband.

Overview of Logic Pro's Main Window.

Below are some observations on Logic Pro, describing some feature and workflow comparisons to Pro Tools, in no particular order:

Audio Region Editing - The most major learning curve for me was in this area. From a Pro Tools user's perspective, Logic Pro's editing tools seemed a bit foreign at first. However, with some of time and practice, it got easier. On the plus side for Logic, they have what's called a "Smart" time grid setting, allowing the user to easily and quickly select exactly what section of audio they want to edit with the mouse, depending on the zoom level they're using in the Edit window. It accurately "snaps" your highlighted selection to the grid for whole bars of audio, or way down to the super-detailed waveform transient level. Pro Tools' Edit window gives the user many of the same edit options, but the grid "snap level" has to be selected manually.

Composite (Comp) Track Editing - Here's an area where I feel that Logic Pro has the advantage. Their "Quick Swipe Comping" feature is well implemented, and probably my favorite feature. Very easy to audition sections of multiple takes by simply swiping the area of the region you want to hear, and clicking that area in a different take lane to hear an alternate version of that particular section - very intuitive. Pro Tools' version of that feature is not bad, but you have to click a "solo" button for each take lane you want to audition, then click another button to commit to the comp selections that you chose. These extra steps makes the process a bit "clunky" in comparison to Logic Pro. A minor gripe perhaps, but I see all those extra mouse clicks adding to the total time spent editing your tracks. Logic Pro also inserts crossfades automatically between your edit points to ensure a smooth transition between takes. Pro Tools requires you to insert the crossfades manually, though you can set it up to perform a "batch fade", which places fades between multiple audio regions.

Quick Swipe Comping makes editing multiple takes a breeze.

Plugins - I've got to say that while I find Logic Pro's audio plugins to be high quality sound-wise, the user interface for many of the plugins controls is the thing I like least about the program. The interface designs on the virtual instruments in particular, range from slightly confusing to downright horrible! The UI's for the effects aren't much better. For that reason, it took me longer than expected to figure out how to get what I needed out of the plugins. Pro Tools plugin UI's are much more user friendly in my opinion, because they tend to resemble a piece of audio hardware, with familiar knobs and buttons on the screen. To its credit, Logic Pro does have some stock plugins that are very useful in mixing and mastering such as multi-band compression and stereo imaging, where in Pro Tools you may have to look to 3rd party plugins for certain things, which will probably require you to spend some extra money. Free plugins that are both compatible with Pro Tools as well as worth the trouble of searching out online are few and far between in my experience.

Logic Pro's Ultrabeat plugin UI - my pick for the worst ever.

Mix Automation - Much like the tools for audio editing, the mix automation tools took some time to get up to speed in Logic Pro. However, it has a very quick way to globally raise or lower all the automation points on a track at once, where it's a bit more involved to do in Pro Tools.

Track Bouncing - Logic Pro has the capability of "bouncing", or rendering, a mix of your project to an audio file "offline", which is faster than real-time. That means that a 4 minute piece of multi-track music would take less than a minute to bounce. Pro Tools versions 10 and prior can only bounce a mix in real time. Meaning whether it's a 30 second piece of music, or an hour long recording, whatever length of time your audio is, that's how long you must wait for it to render a stereo audio file you can burn to CD, import to your iPod, or post online. Offline bouncing is a great time-saver, and is why I give Logic Pro another advantage over Pro Tools. With as many mix versions as I tend to do, it was a nice consolation that I was able to render the mixes and have them ready to play in seconds. I've recently learned that Avid has finally incorporated an offline bounce feature in Pro Tools version 11, due out later this year. Logic Pro can also send the bounce of your mix to your iTunes library as well. Pro Tools didn't have this feature until their version 10 released last year, which I finally upgraded to (more on that in a future post).

CPU Usage - Logic Pro again has an advantage here (for now). You can pile on the virtual instruments and effect plugins and your computer will (usually) not break a sweat. My understanding is that Logic intelligently applies CPU power to your tracks only when audio is actually playing through it, and doesn't when it's not. This is not the case with Pro Tools. The faster your computer is, the better off you will be, but you sometimes have to be careful with your plugin usage with Pro Tools, or you start getting CPU error messages. My understanding, again, is that the upcoming Pro Tools 11 has an all-new audio engine that intelligently distributes CPU power similar to how Logic does.

Media Browser - Integrated into Logic Pro's main window where you can easily navigate through your computer's hard drive to locate files to bring into your currently running project. A nice touch that makes it feel like Logic is tightly integrated with your Mac's entire system. On the other hand, Pro Tools' "Workspace" browser window does the job I suppose, but it's another feature I'd describe as "clunky", and I've never been a big fan of it. Again, advantage, Logic Pro. 

All said and done, once I got over the learning curves, I found Logic Pro to be a versatile, very powerful and capable DAW. My minor gripes aside, you get many awesome features all in one program, features I'm sure I've only scratched the surface of. And with its price of $199 in the Mac App Store, it's the best DAW deal on the market for Mac users that I'm aware of. Many DAW's with comparable features are easily twice the price. In comparison between Logic Pro and Pro Tools, each program has its strengths and weaknesses, which is the real the point of this post. It's about one's own personal preferences. My preference? As much as I've learned using Logic Pro for the past several months and appreciate its strengths, I've got to say that I miss working in Pro Tools. It's the platform I've used most consistently over the past 10 years, and it's the workflow that I know best. However it doesn't mean that I couldn't or wouldn't go back and re-visit Logic from time to time, take advantage of its unique features, and bring my work back into Pro Tools. When necessary, moving project data (the audio track files) from one program to another is actually pretty easy to do.

Logic Pro is currently on version 9 and has been since 2009, an eternity in the computer and software business. Many among the community of Logic users feel "neglected", and say that Apple is long overdue for a new version. I must say that I agree. Far too busy manufacturing iPhones and iPads these days, perhaps? That said, a rumor of a new version has been in the air for a while now. Although I still consider myself a Pro Tools guy first and foremost, I will be looking with interest to see what Apple comes up with for Logic Pro version 10.

One down, two to go for this series. I haven't started recording anything yet, so I've got quite a bit of work ahead of me. I've also got some additional things to talk about, regarding the whole process of recording and mixing this song that I felt should be its own separate post, coming very soon.